1 mouseover reward item
2 check if its better than your old (more vigor) is always better; vigor > "Normal stapoints"
3 check highighted area whether there is determination or not

4 if not take it; if yes take anoter item
if you want to spend ore time you can also check if there are 2 items without deter and take the one with bloodlust as defensive stat but that takes some time, your choice
super fast way:
just take the 1st item, will still be sufficient to level
but determination will make things slower in most cases so i dont recommend this way for a new player