Hi, I was able to get my toons back so I thought I should post how.
First things first:
LOG OUT OF EVERYTHING. Log out from My.com forum, and GPotato sites.
Step 1)
You need a new email. Create a new one.
Step 2) Make a NEW My.com (allods forum) account using the
NEW EMAIL
Step 3) Make sure you are signed onto My.com using the new Email account you just made.
Step 4)
GO HERE if you are from NA Allods, or
GO HERE if you are from EU Allods and click on "Transfer Account" and log into GPotato. YOU HAVE TO USE THE GPOTATO SITE YOUR ACCOUNT IS ON (I was making the mistake of using the EU GPotato site).
Step 5) Once you are logged into
GPotato AND My.com(with your new email). Click on the "Allods Online", this should take you back to Allods page.
Step 6) On the Allods page you will get a message, click on "Migrate". and you're done
Step 7) log into Allods using the new email and CLICK ON THE SERVER YOUR TOON IS ON. It will show 0 toons unless you click on it
Hope This helps