Quoted from "azalin71"
Use the simple build I put up or one of Rozetris builds.
Tested. Has exactly half of my fail dps at single target.
Maybe he followed a "pro" build?
I follow my own builds based on what I've seen and figured through on my own. Admittedly, the last time I did Pally DPS was before Incineration was split into being both phys and fire/holy. They also changed a few things that made Ret/Chains more enticing, I believe. That said, I'm surprised you were dealing less than half of your original build's DPS with the suggested build. Can you remember off-hand what your general rotation was? Compared with the build you posted, there are some differences in how the build I suggested works. I won't say outright that your build is bad, given I can't test on my own at the moment what your build does, but it does run contrary to the norm. If it does lead to superior DPS, well, weirder things have happened.
That said, the build you posted does have some of the problems that Ara mentioned, though I've noticed you have since deleted the build you suggested. Still, I would definitely have picked up the rubies for damage buffs when vows fade. The Law and Order rubies actually are being wasted at the moment, too, given you have no source of Condemnation. Now, you never want to actually cast Condemn, given it eats a canon. The Interdiction rubies that cast Condemn at the end of Rage of Light are what you want to use for getting Condemn. Interestingly, you can actually cast Condemn via Interdiction even if you don't have a single talent point invested in Condemn. You could probably switch the Solstice ruby over to pick up at least one Interdiction ruby if you're purely interested in DPS, that would let you make use of Law and Order. I would probably also drop the SoJ defense boost rubies in order to pick up one of the damage buffs that procs when a vow fades. You ideally want all four rubies, but you may have to subtract that from the max HP rubies or simply wait until you have two more rubies for use.
Regardless, I would drop SoJ down to rank 2 in order to get your Vow of Purity up to rank 3. On the rest of the talent side, you are using the base versions of both Seal and Ret, and you WILL see a damage boost by using the evolved versions of those skills at max rank. I don't know if you have the available talent points to do so, though, and it would probably require you drop SoJ to rank 1, remove Screen, and lower or remove both of your tear skills.
I'm not sure if this would make for the BEST DPS, but it would certainly optimize what you're currently familiar with. Doing what you know generally results in better damage than learning something new.