But the more important question to ask is if allods was/is more entertaining??
Allods lost or gained very little entertainment value with expansions, it's mostly the same all the time.
oldest WoW (vanilla/tbc) had a greater entertainment value than Allods
Wrath of the Lich King had about the same entertainment value as Allods
Any WoW version past that lost any entertainment value it had entirely, so Allods wins by far now
at least this is my view on that
Edit: Oh forgot to mention that introduction of p2p model to Allods increased it's entertainment value very substantially for me. Above points apply to F2P Allods only.
Subscription version easily has an entertainment value on par with oldest WoW if not greater.